Full-Service Qualified Intermediary · Nationwide ServiceCALL TODAY: 513-402-8911
1031 Federal Exchange
Schedule a Call513-402-8911
Call Now
Process

How to Choose a 1031 Exchange Company: What to Look for...

June 26, 2026
By Attorney Steve Wolterman, CES

How to Choose a 1031 Exchange Company: What to Look for...

Not all 1031 exchange companies are the same. Learn the 7 criteria that separate a trustworthy Qualified Intermediary from one that puts your exchange at risk.

How to Choose a 1031 Exchange Company

Choosing a 1031 exchange company is one of the most consequential decisions you will make in the entire exchange process. The Qualified Intermediary (QI) holds your sale proceeds, manages your compliance deadlines, and prepares the legal documentation that the IRS requires. If your QI fails, mishandles funds, or makes a documentation error, your exchange fails and you owe the full capital gains tax you were trying to defer.

The challenge is that the term "Qualified Intermediary" is not a licensed profession in most states. Unlike real estate agents or attorneys, QIs are not required to pass a standardized exam, maintain a license, or carry a minimum level of insurance. Anyone can legally call themselves a Qualified Intermediary. That reality makes the selection criteria below more important, not less.

1. Look for Industry Certifications

The most meaningful credential in the industry is the Certified Exchange Specialist (CES) designation, awarded by the Federation of Exchange Accommodators (FEA). Earning the CES requires passing a rigorous examination covering IRC Section 1031, IRS regulations, and exchange mechanics. It also requires ongoing continuing education to maintain. A QI who holds the CES designation has demonstrated a baseline level of technical competence that goes beyond simply hanging out a shingle.

The FEA itself is worth noting. It is the national trade association for the exchange industry and maintains a code of ethics that member companies agree to follow. Working with an FEA member company provides an additional layer of accountability.

2. Verify How Your Funds Are Held

Your exchange proceeds must be held by the QI from the time your relinquished property closes until you close on your replacement property. During that window, which can be up to 180 days, the QI is holding funds that belong to you. The critical question is: how are those funds protected?

A reputable QI will hold your funds in a segregated, qualified escrow account or a qualified trust account at an FDIC-insured institution. This means your money is kept separate from the QI's operating funds and cannot be used for the company's own expenses. Ask any QI you are considering to explain their fund-holding structure in writing. If the answer is vague or they cannot point to a specific account structure, that is a serious warning sign.

3. Confirm They Carry Fidelity Bond and Errors and Omissions Insurance

Even a well-intentioned QI can make a mistake. Fidelity bond coverage protects you if a QI employee steals or misappropriates your funds. Errors and omissions (E&O) insurance covers you if the QI makes a professional mistake that causes your exchange to fail. Ask for proof of both coverages and verify the coverage amounts are meaningful relative to your transaction size.

4. Evaluate Their Experience With Your Property Type

A QI who primarily handles residential single-family exchanges may not be the right choice for a complex commercial transaction, a reverse exchange, or an improvement exchange. Ask specifically about their experience with exchanges similar to yours. How many reverse exchanges have they completed? Do they have experience with the property type you are selling and buying? A QI who is learning on your transaction is a liability.

5. Assess Responsiveness and Communication

The 45-day identification deadline and the 180-day closing deadline are absolute. There are no extensions for personal emergencies, market conditions, or communication failures. A QI who is slow to return calls or emails during the sales process will be just as slow when you are trying to meet a deadline. Test their responsiveness before you sign anything.

6. Understand the Fee Structure

QI fees vary widely. Some companies charge a flat fee per exchange, others charge based on transaction size, and some charge additional fees for identification amendments, extensions, or complex transaction structures. Get the full fee schedule in writing before you engage. A lower upfront fee that comes with hidden charges for every additional service is not necessarily a better deal than a higher flat fee that covers everything.

7. Verify They Are Not a Disqualified Person

Treasury Regulation 1.1031(k)-1(k) prohibits you from using certain parties as your QI. These "disqualified persons" include your attorney, your accountant, your real estate agent, and anyone who has acted as your agent in the prior two years. Using a disqualified person as your QI invalidates the exchange entirely.

Why Attorney-Led QI Services Matter

One meaningful differentiator in the industry is whether the QI has legal counsel involved in the exchange process. An attorney-led QI can review the exchange agreement, identify potential disqualification risks, and provide guidance on complex scenarios that a purely administrative QI cannot. This is particularly valuable in reverse exchanges, improvement exchanges, and transactions involving partnership interests or LLC structures.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire a 1031 Exchange Company

Before signing an exchange agreement, ask these specific questions: How are my exchange funds held, and in what type of account? Are those funds FDIC-insured? Do you carry fidelity bond coverage, and what is the coverage amount? Do you carry E&O insurance? What is your CES certification status? How many exchanges of my type have you completed in the last 12 months? What is your complete fee schedule, including any fees for amendments or extensions?

A reputable QI will answer all of these questions directly and without hesitation. If you encounter evasiveness, vague answers, or pressure to sign quickly, trust that instinct and keep looking.

At 1031 Federal Exchange, our principal is a Certified Exchange Specialist and a licensed attorney. Your funds are held in segregated qualified escrow accounts at FDIC-insured institutions, and we carry both fidelity bond and E&O coverage. Call us at 513-402-8911 or start your exchange online.

Author

Attorney and Certified Exchange Specialist with over 20 years of experience guiding real estate investors through 1031 exchanges nationwide. Member of the Federation of Exchange Accommodators (FEA).

Ready to Start Your Exchange?

Fill out the form below and attorney Steve Wolterman will contact you within 1 business day.