Full-Service Qualified Intermediary · Nationwide ServiceCALL TODAY: 513-402-8911
1031 Federal Exchange
Schedule a Call513-402-8911
Call Now
Case StudiesShort-Term Rental
Case Study: Short-Term Rental

Exiting the STR Market: Deferring $46,900 in Taxes

Transitioning from high-turnover vacation rentals to stable long-term assets through a 1031 Exchange.

$46,900
Taxes Deferred
Federal, State & Recapture
$485,000
Equity Preserved
Full equity reinvested
$650,000
New Asset Value
Long-term rental duplex
Licensed Qualified Intermediary IRS-Compliant Exchange Handling Steve Wolterman, Attorney, CES Nationwide Service
1

The Challenge

Burned out by constant turnover and regulatory changes in the short-term rental market, the investor wanted to exit their Airbnb property. Purchased for $350,000 and sold for $550,000, an outright sale would have triggered a $46,900 tax bill and left them with less capital to redeploy.

2

The Solution

To qualify, the property met the IRS Safe Harbor under Rev. Proc. 2008-16: rented at fair market value for at least 14 days in each of the two prior years, with personal use not exceeding 14 days or 10% of total rented days. 1031 Federal Exchange confirmed qualification, held the $485,000 in proceeds, and managed the exchange timeline.

3

The Result

The investor closed on a $650,000 long-term duplex with a new $165,000 mortgage, deferring all taxes and simplifying their investment strategy. Trading one high-stress STR for a stable, long-term rental dramatically reduced their weekly management burden.

Side-by-Side Comparison

The financial difference between selling outright and using a 1031 Exchange

ItemWithout 1031With 1031
Sale Price$550,000$550,000
Mortgage Payoff$65,000$65,000
Net Proceeds$485,000$485,000
Adjusted Basis$310,000$310,000
Taxable Gain$240,000$240,000 — DEFERRED
Federal Capital Gains (15%)$28,500$0
Depreciation Recapture (25%)$10,000$0
Ohio State Tax (~3.5%)$8,400$0
Total Tax Bill$46,900$0
Capital Available to Reinvest$438,100$485,000
Bonus: Key Rule for STR Owners: Personal use must not exceed 14 days per year or 10% of total rented days, whichever is greater. Maintaining accurate rental logs before pursuing an exchange is essential.

Ready to Protect Your Equity?

Speak directly with Steve Wolterman, Attorney at Law and Certified Exchange Specialist, about your specific property and timeline.

No obligation. We answer questions before you commit to anything.

Note: These figures are representative models based on real transaction structures we have facilitated in the Ohio market. Client details have been kept confidential, but the exchange mechanics and tax outcomes reflect what we see regularly in deals like this.